Disclaimer: This article contains spoilers.
You’ve likely seen plenty of competitions in schools and colleges where students vie to become the ‘Student of the Year.’ But in this series, the students are willing to go to such extremes, even taking each other’s lives to claim that title.
In this world, friendships, love, and relationships hold absolutely no value.
Everyone is obsessed with winning the competition at any cost, leading to such shocking events that, at times, you can’t even tell if it’s a college or a den for criminals.
On top of that, there’s a murder mystery woven in, casting suspicion on everyone. But the truth that eventually emerges and the way this competition concludes is a whole new level of madness.
So, let’s dive in and see exactly what’s going on in this series.
Aditi Enters St. Teresa College to Investigate Aayesha’s Death
The story begins at a large college called St. Teresa, where a girl named Aayesha is a student. One day, Aayesha’s body is discovered in a frozen lake near the college. Before her death, she had recorded a video in which visible injuries could be seen on her face.
The police claim that Aayesha died by suicide, but her twin sister, Aditi, refuses to believe this, not only because of the injuries on Aayesha’s face, but also because a locket Aayesha always wore around her neck was missing in the video.
Five years earlier, an incident had occurred between the sisters that led them to stop speaking to each other entirely. Despite this, Aditi knows her sister well, and she decides to uncover the true cause of her death.
Meanwhile, Aditi learns that a month prior, the college Dean, D’Souza, had also died under mysterious circumstances, a case that was likewise ruled a suicide.
With two deaths linked to the college occurring within a single month, Aditi suspects that something sinister is going on. To expose the truth, she decides to enrol in the same college herself.
Here, she meets Tara, Aayesha’s best friend. She also encounters Aayesha’s boyfriend, Sid, as well as Rehaan, who had feelings for Aayesha.
However, after meeting them, Aditi’s suspicions only deepened, especially since Sid also bears injury marks on his face. Furthermore, both these young men were already bitter rivals over Aayesha.
Additionally, Aditi discovers Aayesha’s former room, which she once shared with a girl nicknamed ‘Babydoll ‘, and realises she had a very strained relationship. In short, almost everyone in Aayesha’s circle was resentful toward her. Yet, what troubled Aditi the most was something far more peculiar.
As it turns out, Aayesha was wearing a red tracksuit at the time of her death, even though the college authorities claimed that no such tracksuit was ever used there. So, why was Aayesha wearing those clothes? Aditi finds the answer that very night when, while following Rehaan, she arrives at a secret door within the college.
Using a locket, Rehaan opens the door and heads inside; Aditi follows him in. Once inside, she discovers that several college students are wearing the exact same red tracksuit, all of them having gathered to participate in a secret competition called ‘Student of the Year.
The Secret Student of the Year Competition
Bro, this isn’t your typical college competition. Winning it brings money, power, and the kind of recognition that can completely transform one’s life. But to win, students have to play such dangerous games that they could even cost someone their life.
For instance, in the very first round, only 30 torches are placed before 50 students; only those who manage to secure a torch get to advance to the next round. As a result, everyone begins fighting one another.
Aditi jumps into the fray and manages to secure a torch. However, when the competition organizers find out, they demand that she leave, they don’t want her to be a part of the game. But Aditi makes it clear that she isn’t going anywhere until she wins the competition and uncovers the truth behind her sister’s death.”
Aditi learns that Sid’s father and elder brother had both won this competition in the past, which puts immense pressure on Sid to win it as well.
For students like Rehaan and Babydoll, meanwhile, the competition serves as a potential escape from poverty.
Consequently, everyone here is desperate to win.
Who Had a Motive to Kill Aayesha?
As Aditi becomes part of this game, she begins to grow closer to Aayesha’s friends. However, certain screenshots go viral, revealing that Sid had once beaten Aayesha severely.
Aditi sees this and thinks Sid might have killed Ayesha. She gets super angry, beats Sid up, quits his group, and joins Rehaan. But later, Sid confesses to everyone that he hit Aayesha, saying his mental state wasn’t right back then, he got help for it, and Aayesha forgave him.
But Aditi’s suspicions were not limited to Sid; she discovered something about Babydoll as well, something that suggests she, too, had a motive to seek revenge against Aayesha.
In reality, BabyDoll came from a middle-class family. However, at this college, which was filled with wealthy students, she pretended to be very rich. When Aayesha and Tara discovered the truth, they went to BabyDoll’s home, took photographs, and exposed her poverty to the entire college, even going so far as to solicit “donations” for her college fees.
This caused BabyDoll great humiliation.
Later, however, BabyDoll reveals that she has forgiven Aayesha, and she even begins to help Aditi.
Meanwhile, Rehaan was also hiding something. He had borrowed money from a loan app, but when he couldn’t repay it, the app operators threatened to leak his private photos. Because of this, he even resorted to stealing money from his own mother.
Aditi found herself unable to discern who was telling the truth and who was lying. Then, a major clue emerged from Aayesha’s laptop: the password was “Didi” (elder sister), a sign that, despite being apart for five years, Aayesha had never forgotten her sister.
Following this, Aditi and Babydoll manage to recover Aayesha’s missing mobile phone from a shop. Since the two sisters look identical, Aditi is able to unlock the phone using its face-recognition feature.
Aditi discovers videos from the night of Aayesha’s death and is shocked to see that a large number of students were present at the college that night, contrary to the claims of Aayesha’s friends, who had insisted that no event took place.
What Really Happened on the Night of Aayesha’s Death?
Aditi gathers everyone involved and forces them to reveal the truth. They confess that a round of the ‘Student of the Year’ competition was indeed taking place that night. During this, Sid and Rehaan got into an argument over Aayesha, as Sid did not want her to compete against him.
Distressed by the conflict, Aayesha begins to cry. Tara suggests she go to the restroom to fix her makeup.
Meanwhile, the other students, blindfolded, are led toward the lake, where they are tasked with finding a torch. Aayesha, however, never arrives, leading everyone to assume she has dropped out of the competition.
After Ayesha’s death is reported, Sid and his brother review the CCTV footage, which reveals that she fell into the water when the ice broke while she was trying to pick up a flashlight on the lake. While everyone else assumes it was an accidental death, Aditi rejects this theory after testing the ice herself and finding it too thick to break easily.
Furthermore, the glass in the washroom window Aayesha last visited had been replaced. This led Aditi to suspect that someone locked Aayesha in the washroom and released a toxic gas. However, Aayesha managed to break the glass and escape; subsequently, someone also deliberately broke the ice on the lake.
In short, this was no accident. Someone had meticulously planned an attempt to kill Aayesha.
Aditi and Ayesha’s Painful Past Revealed
But there is another aspect to this, which requires us to look back at Aditi and Aayesha’s childhood.
Their mother had them involved in acting from a young age. While Aayesha enjoyed it, Aditi detested it. To make matters worse, their parents were constantly fighting. One day, the two sisters devised a plan to cause a commotion on a film set, hoping it would put an end to their parents’ arguments.
The idea was Aayesha’s. During the incident, Aayesha threw something that struck a man, resulting in his death. Everyone assumed Aditi was responsible, but Aayesha refused to admit her fault.
Consequently, Aditi bore the brunt of the blame and the scolding, and following this event, their parents eventually separated.
Aayesha went to live with her mother, while Aditi went with her father. At the time, Aditi was so angry with her sister that, in a fit of rage, she had even wished for Aayesha to die.
Now that Aayesha was truly dead, Aditi was deeply remorseful for having said that. But later, she discovered that, over the past five years, her mother and Aayesha had made numerous attempts to reach out to her, calling her, writing letters, and sending gifts.
Aditi, however, never received any of these, as her father had been hiding them from her. In reality, he had been pocketing the money Aditi earned from her acting work, and he had no intention of letting her return to her mother and sister.
Upon learning the truth, Aditi left her father and reconnected with her mother. Yet, the truth behind her sister’s murder remained to be uncovered.
Meanwhile, the police releases the post-mortem report of Aayesha. In which his death was declared an accident. But Aditi suspects that the real report is being hidden.
So, with the help of her friends and mother, she sneaks into the police station and gets the real report. In which it is revealed that a poisonous chemical was present in Aayesha’s body.
Meaning, an attempt was made to kill him even before he drowned in the lake. Crucially, this same chemical is also linked to the death of Dean D’Souza, leading to the arrest of the current college Dean, Kashyap.
Tara’s Dark Secret and the Real Killer Revealed
But the story doesn’t end there; Aditi discovers that Tara had been lying about her mother; the woman she claimed was her mother at college was not her biological mother at all. When Tara’s real mother finally surfaces, a major secret is brought to light.
In reality, Tara was the daughter of Dean D’Souza. However, Dean D’Souza had never acknowledged Tara or her mother, which led Tara to harbor a deep hatred for her father from a young age.
Driven by this, she secured a scholarship to the very college where her father served as the Dean. Even after she arrived there, D’Souza still refused to acknowledge her as his daughter.
Consequently, Tara devised a plan for revenge. Together with Aayesha, she created a fake social media profile and began chatting with D’Souza.
Believing he was conversing with another woman, D’Souza started flirting with her and even sent private photographs. This was exactly what Tara had hoped for. She then called D’Souza, threatening to make his private photos go viral, and revealed that she was, in fact, his own daughter.
Tara’s blackmail was so relentless that she ultimately told him that if he wished to avoid public humiliation, he should take his own life.
Following this, D’Souza died, though there were suspicious circumstances surrounding his car and the chemicals found inside it.
Aayesha eventually learned of the threats Tara had made, and, deeply disturbed by this, she ended their friendship. She insisted that Tara must reveal the truth about what happened to D’Souza.
This is where Tara’s real plan begins. If Aayesha were to speak up, the whole truth about Tara would be exposed; therefore, Tara decides to eliminate her own best friend. We then learn what actually transpired on the night of Aayesha’s death.
That night, Tara deliberately incites a fight between Sid and Rehaan, knowing that witnessing their conflict would distress Aayesha, which is exactly what happens.
As Aayesha begins to cry, Tara sends her to the restroom to fix her makeup. Unbeknownst to Aayesha, Tara has already planted a toxic chemical inside.
As soon as Aayesha enters, Tara locks the door from the outside. Aayesha’s condition begins to deteriorate, but she manages to break the window glass and escape. She eventually reaches the lakeside, where Tara, who had assumed Aayesha would die in the restroom, is shocked to see her alive. Tara quickly pivots to a new plan.
Approaching Aayesha, Tara pretends to apologise and promises that once the competition concludes, she will reveal the truth regarding the D’Souza matter to everyone.
Aayesha, believing her, falls for the ruse. In the midst of this, Tara offers her some water which has been laced with a sedative.
Aayesha’s condition deteriorates further. In this state, Tara hands her a flashlight and claims that another one is placed in the middle of the lake, asking for Aayesha’s help to retrieve it.
Ayesha, wanting to assist her friend, heads out onto the lake, but, under the influence of the drugs, she loses consciousness. Tara then breaks the ice on the lake and pushes Aayesha into the water, ultimately causing her death.
In short, the very girl whom Aayesha considered her best friend was the one who killed her. Tara did all of this solely to ensure that her dark secret from the past remained hidden.
When Aditi and the others finally discover the truth, Tara shows no real remorse.
On the contrary, she argues that she had only told D’Souza to die; the decision to end his life was his own. As for Aayesha, Tara claims she had to kill her because Aayesha refused to keep quiet.
Student of the Year After Dark Ending Explained: Who Wins?
Hearing this, Aditi’s anger erupts, and she gives Tara a severe thrashing. Meanwhile, another form of madness was unfolding, the final round of the ‘Student of the Year’ competition had begun. The first person to reach the trophy would be declared the winner. Rehaan, too, was in a bad state, having also been attacked by Tara.
Sid now realizes that the pursuit of winning this competition is ruining everyone’s lives. Friends have turned into enemies, and things have escalated to the point of murder.
Consequently, Sid wants to put an end to the game for good. However, the guards present there prevent him from doing so, as the rules dictate that the game cannot end until a winner is determined.
In the end, Aditi and another player head toward the trophy. Suddenly, Tara, who had fallen to the ground after being beaten by Aditi, gets back up and reaches the trophy first. It is then announced that Tara has become this year’s ‘Student of the Year’ and that all her wishes will now be granted.
Aditi and everyone else are left stunned; the very girl who murdered her own best friend ends up winning this dangerous competition.
However, the most significant unanswered questions remain: Is Tara arrested once her true colours are revealed? What does Aditi do next? And who are the people behind this competition? None of this is shown.
The series simply ends with Tara’s victory, which suggests that a second season might be in the works! Are you excited about that? Do let me know in the comments. And if you enjoyed this explanation, be sure to share your thoughts in the comments as well!