Student of the Year (After Dark) Ending Explained: What the Hell Was That Ending?

Disclaimer: This article contains spoilers.

What the fuck! What the hell just happened? How did Tara win all of a sudden? I mean, you made a criminal the winner and then just ended the series right there!

What is even going on here? There’s a line in the movie 3 Idiots: “What exactly are you trying to say?” and that’s the same question I have for the makers of this web series and for Karan Johar.

Hello friends, I’m Ayush, and I’ve just finished watching Student of the Year: After Dark.

The Story Behind Aayesha’s Death

Image courtesy: Respective copyright holder

To begin with, let’s look at the backstory: it all centres on St. Teresa Heritage School, where the body of Aayesha Malik, one of the school’s most popular students, is found in the frozen Barakhali Lake.

The police dismiss it as an accident, but Aayesha’s twin sister, Aditi, refuses to believe that.

Determined to uncover the truth behind her sister’s death, Aditi enrolls in the same school. There, she discovers a secret “Student of the Year” competition, where the winner is granted any wish they desire.

However, this is no ordinary competition. The rounds are so dangerous and psychologically intense that they force every student’s hidden secrets and vulnerabilities to the surface.

As Aditi gradually grows closer to Aayesha’s friends, she attempts to figure out which one of them might be connected to her sister’s death. 

Aayesha was the most popular girl in school, but while her life appeared perfect from the outside, it was, in reality, deeply complicated.

As children, both she and Aditi had been child artists. Following conflicts between their parents and an accident that occurred on a film set, the relationship between the two sisters deteriorated. Aditi was blamed for the accident, and Aayesha failed to stand by her.

Later, Aayesha moved to a school with her mother and cultivated a ‘perfect’ image. Yet, beneath the surface, she harboured the guilt of her past and various hidden secrets.

Her trauma stemmed from:

The guilt from her childhood;

The breakdown of her family;

And the constant pressure to always appear perfect.

The Characters and Their Hidden Traumas

Let’s talk about Aditi, the main protagonist of this story. Following her mother’s rejection and her separation from her sister during childhood, she went to live with her father.

After Aayesha’s death, Aditi arrives at the same school, determined to uncover the truth. Her journey is not merely about finding her sister’s killer; it is also about coming to terms with an incomplete relationship and overcoming her deep-seated guilt.

Her trauma stemmed from her mother’s rejection, her estrangement from her sister, and the lingering regret over losing her.

Then there was Tara, Aayesha’s best friend. Deep down, she harboured a profound emotional conflict: she was the daughter of Dean D’Souza, yet he had never acknowledged her, all to protect his own reputation.

Tara constantly craved his approval. Over time, this desire morphed into an obsessive need to win the ‘Student of the Year’ competition.

She manipulated her father to the point where he was driven to suicide; when Aayesha discovered this dark secret, Tara eliminated her as well.

At the core of Tara’s trauma lay her father’s rejection and her own desperate, obsessive drive to prove her worth.

Aayesha had a boyfriend named Siddharth. Despite coming from a wealthy and privileged family, he lived under the pressure of his father’s and brother’s expectations. He harboured deep-seated insecurity and anger, which were reflected in his behaviour.

Following Aayesha’s death, his suspicious conduct raised several questions. He struggled with a complex mix of family pressure, personal insecurity, and confusion regarding his own true identity.

Then there was Rehaan, who had been in love with Aayesha since the eighth grade. However, his affection remained unrequited; he was always present in Aayesha’s life, yet he never became a priority for her. 

Even within their elite school, he felt alienated from the others. His trauma stemmed from rejection, unrequited love, a sense of inferiority, and a lack of financial means.

Then there was another friend, a roommate of ‘Babydoll’ Aayesha, whose own identity had become overshadowed by Aayesha’s popularity. She felt jealous of her and, at times, took out her frustration on Aditi.

Her internal conflict stemmed from constant jealousy and the frustration of failing to establish an identity of her own.

Additionally, there was a guy named JD, who was Tara’s boyfriend.

Who Killed Aayesha? The Final Episode Explained

Now, let’s move on to the final episode—the stage where the competition’s most psychological round unfolds.

In this round, the contestants are subjected to hypnosis, forcing them to confront the secrets buried deep within their greatest fears. This is where the story’s biggest mystery is finally revealed.

Aditi discovers that her sister wasn’t murdered by some stranger, but by her own closest friend, Tara.

Tara’s motive went beyond just getting Aayesha out of the way; she wanted to conceal a truth involving her own father and satisfy her obsessive need to win the competition.

Tara drugged Aayesha and drowned her in Barakhali Lake, making the death appear to be an accident.

In a cruel twist, the very person Aditi trusted most throughout the series turns out to be her sister’s killer.

Why Did Tara Win the Competition? The Ending Explained

But bro, how does Tara end up winning in the end?

At this point, the series takes a truly interesting and deeply disturbing turn.

When the truth about Tara is revealed, the other contestants turn against her. Aditi and the others demand an explanation. The situation escalates, with talk even surfacing about bringing the competition to an end.

Yet, amidst this chaos, Tara picks up the trophy, and the series concludes right there.

The question arises: why is a murderer standing there holding the trophy? The creators intentionally crafted this ending to show that, in this competition, the price of winning has come to outweigh humanity itself.

Tara lost her father and murdered her best friend; she exploited every relationship for her own gain—and yet, in the final scene, she is the one seen with the trophy. However, she is never officially declared the winner, nor is her arrest or punishment depicted.

Consequently, this serves as an open ending perhaps leaving the door ajar for a potential next season or, at the very least, an unresolved conflict.

What Is the Real Meaning Behind the Ending?

In my view, the most significant aspect of this series is its depiction of a competition where winning becomes a goal for the students that transcends even life itself.

Every character here is, in some way, running from their past. Some crave their parents’ love, while others seek acceptance, popularity, or a sense of identity.

However, when the desire to prove oneself turns into an obsession, an individual loses the ability to distinguish between right and wrong.

Tara is the prime example of this. She was wronged, but instead of processing her pain and moving forward, she chose to destroy the lives of others, and this is the darkest message of the series’ conclusion.

Winning a competition does not necessarily mean being the most capable person. Sometimes, victory belongs to those who, despite losing everything, continue to justify their own mistakes.

Ultimately, this is a story about young people who lose themselves in the pursuit of familial acceptance and validation.

Let me know what you thought of the series and this explanation; if you have any other questions, please feel free to share them in the comment section.

Leave a Comment