Student of the Year 2 was such a massive success that there’s now a follow-up show called Student of the Year: After Dark. But just how intense is this “dark” side? Let’s break it all down today.
Student of the Year: After Dark All Episodes Review

Student of the Year: After Dark is set in an elite school and revolves around a pair of twin sisters. One of them has died; the police have ruled it a suicide, but her sister believes it was murder. The surviving sister enrolls in the school to investigate, only to discover a game taking place there known as “Student of the Year.” To find out what happens next, you’ll have to watch the show. It consists of six episodes; most are half an hour long, while the finale runs for 45 minutes.
A Good Concept With Disappointing Execution

If I had to sum up this show in one line, the core concept was actually quite good. But the execution? It falls flat, much like my own childhood dream of becoming a cricketer.
For the first five episodes, it’s decent enough watchable, at least. But then you reach the climax of the big reveal of who the murderer is, and what follows after that… Well, it’s just baffling.
I honestly can’t tell if the first season has actually concluded, or if there’s a second season on the way. The way they wrapped things up is so bizarre, it’s completely beyond my comprehension, bro.
I mean, it’s beyond the grasp of my heart, my brain, my lungs, my kidneys, everything!
Even though the show isn’t particularly long, it still manages to be incredibly boring, like someone activated a ‘slow-motion’ cheat code. Everything just crawls along at a glacial pace. I managed to sit through it, though that part, at least, didn’t bother me too much.
I expected that the reveal of the killer would be a mind-bending moment. The identity of the killer does come as a shock, leaving you thinking, “Wait, *this* was the killer?” The way it’s presented is incredibly flat and lacklustre.
The narrative suggests that this “game” is being played with great secrecy, yet there’s nothing about the game itself that warrants such a high level of covertness. And I’m not even talking about the logic here.
Look, if your story lacks logic or common sense, your conviction and the strength with which you present your vision must be so powerful that the audience forgets to think logically. Just look at Rajamouli.
Rajamouli might show anything on screen, but his conviction is so strong that we end up believing in his world.
When that kind of conviction is present in the direction, everything starts to feel relatable; you begin to trust what you’re seeing. But here, that simply isn’t the case.
Performances and Overall Verdict
As for Shanaya Kapoor, her acting isn’t consistent; she’s quite good in some parts, but completely flat in others.
Some of the characters are truly eccentric and manage to connect with you; it’s actually enjoyable to follow their journeys.
Overall, it’s a decent show, certainly much better than Student of the Year 2. That said, some groups on Instagram will inevitably label it a “masterpiece,” claiming that nothing like it has ever been made in India before.
Let me be clear: that’s simply not the case. Steer clear, consider yourself warned!
I’d give the show a 5.5 to 6 out of 10. Why? Well, many people haven’t seen this particular style of teenage drama, so they might find it quite good. But if you’re already familiar with this genre, you probably won’t enjoy it as much.
Regarding parental guidance: there are no nude or vulgar scenes, though you will hear some profanity here and there.
So, friends, that’s my review of Student of the Year: After Dark. I hope you found it helpful!